Sherwin Williams Eggshell Vs Satin – Which Color To Pick?

When it comes to decorating your new home or renovating your house, the first thing that crosses your mind is picking the right color for it.

Alongside painting the walls, the woodworks in the house also need paint jobs, and Sherwin Williams paints are the best to get both jobs done.

But in the Sherwin Williams Eggshell Vs Satin dilemma, which color should you go for?

Sherwin Williams Eggshell has a lower sheen which gives the color a matt outlook. On the other hand, the Satin color provides a much glossier finish due to its higher sheen. Eggshell provides an aesthetic look for your door and windows while Satin gives your walls a more robust look.

Nevertheless, there are still a few more factors to consider before deciding on a final color pick. This article will help you to be accurate in your color pick.

6 Comparison Factors Between Sherwin Williams Eggshell And Satin

Before you make a renovation plan and rush to the paint shop, consider doing some research on not just how the paint will look on your walls, but how much it will serve your purpose.

I have created a comparison list for your convenience so you don’t have to. As a dedicated user of Sherwin Williams paints, let me take you through the whole journey.

SheenLower SheenHigher SheenBoth
DurabilityLess DurableMore DurableSatin
CleaningTakes Long to CleanEasier to CleanSatin
ApplyingEasier to ApplyEasy to ApplyEggshell
UsageLow and Medium Traffic AreaHigh Traffic AreaBoth
Where to BuyBuy from eBayBuy from Amazon

Now that you have a basic idea on which paint is what, let’s dive into the details.

Comparison Factor 1: Sheen

The sheen of paint indicates how much light is reflected from the paint finish. Sherwin Williams’ paints are no different.

The Eggshell has a lower sheen which means it has a lower reflective ability. However, the Satin sits high at the sheen table, reflecting more light than the Eggshell.

If you are planning for a flat paint job, you should always go with Eggshell. On the contrary, go with Satin if you want to have a 3-D look inside your house and brighten the dark areas.


Both Eggshell and Satin are good choices for paint, but it solely depends on your purpose. Both of them can fill up your expectations if you can match their contrast with your home.

Comparison Factor 2: Finish

With a subtle sheen, the Eggshell reflects less light, giving it a matt finish on the applied surface area. But since the Eggshell has less luster, it will create depth in a space without getting too shiny.

Satin has a higher sheen which gives it a glossy look. Its beautiful luster provides a velvety appearance and makes it shine on the surface.   


The matt finish of Eggshell creates a sense of space in your house while the glossy finish of Satin gives your home a modern look. 

Depending on your decorating theme, you can easily choose any one of them.

Comparison Factor 3: Durability

Don’t you hate it when you see your freshly painted wall scuffed? Yes, me too.

Between the Eggshell and the Satin, the Eggshell is less durable and more likely to get marked or scuffed.

Satin is more durable and it gets scuffed very rarely, which makes Satin a perfect choice for high-traffic areas inside the house. 

Also, it picks up less dirt than Eggshell which makes Satin more durable in comparison.  


Both of these paints can be used according to your preferences and they serve almost in the same way when it comes to color.

However, in terms of durability, Satin is one step ahead of Eggshell.

Comparison Factor 4: Cleaning

To be honest, there isn’t much of a difference in cleaning and maintaining both of these paints.

Nonetheless, the glossier finish of Satin makes it easier to clean and maintain. On the other hand, the usual matt finish of Eggshell takes a little effort to get clean. 

It is because the surface of the Eggshell is a bit rougher than the Satin’s and it takes longer to wipe off any dirt from it. 

You can use warm soapy water to clean them both, but if the stain is stubborn, you may use diluted sugar soap but gently.


Undoubtedly, Satin wins this segment with its glossy finish. The flat surface of this paint helps to get off the stains without any extra effort.

Comparison Factor 5: Applying

Eggshell and the Satin don’t have much difference when it comes to the application. They have a similar viscosity or thickness, but it can change if you are using any other brand than Sherwin Williams.

Usually Eggshell is easier to apply because you don’t need to have much experience in painting with it. Any novice painter like you and me can get a decent finish with the Eggshell.


If we consider the easy application for both of these paints, Eggshell will have a headstart on this race. Because not only it covers the defects of the surface, just one coating of this paint is enough to give your home a new look. 

Comparison Factor 6: Usage

It is very important to know which paint you should use to decorate specific areas of your house and what will be the final result.

The matt finish of the Eggshell is perfect for walls in low and medium-traffic areas inside your house. You can use this paint to color your bedroom walls or kitchen.

However, the Satin paint should be used in high-traffic areas like living rooms and hallways for its beautiful luster. 


Both Eggshell and Satin serve different purposes according to their usage. Eggshell provides depth to the area and Satin provides shine.

So now you can exactly tell how you should renovate your home when it comes to painting it completely.

When Should You Pick Sherwin Williams Eggshell?

Now it comes down to the most important question, when should you go for the Sherwin Williams Eggshell coating?

If you are planning to decorate your kitchen, bedroom, or dining room, Sherwin Williams Eggshell is the perfect option for you.

It is a durable paint that doesn’t pick up dirt easily and can be emphasized with brighter lighting.

Also, if your walls have any bumps or defects, the matt finish of Eggshell coating will hide those spots seamlessly.

ImageNamePriceWhere to buy?
Sherwin Williams Emerald Celery 6421 Egg ShellSherwin Williams Emerald Celery 6421 Egg Shell$84.99Buy from eBay

Should You Pick Eggshell or Satin For the Bedroom?

The bedroom is the most comforting place in your entire world, isn’t that right?

So the bedroom needs a soothing, matt color that can comfort your eyes. In this case, Satin will not be appropriate for the bedroom because of its glossy and shiny look.

That’s why you should rather pick Eggshell for your bedroom.

When Should You Pick Sherwin Williams Satin?

Because of its durability, Satin paint is widely used in spaces where people go the most in your houses, such as living rooms, hallways, and sitting areas. 

Sherwin Williams Satin is a popular choice for trim if you want to emphasize the architecture of your house. 

Also, this paint coating is really easy to clean, which is why it is preferred at high-traffic areas inside your house.

However, you need to have a spotless surface to apply a Satin paint coating on it, otherwise, the luster of it will highlight the imperfections of the surface.

ImageNamePriceWhere to Buy?
Sherwin-Williams Finish 1 FC750-1 2.1 VOC SatinSherwin-Williams Finish 1 FC750-1 2.1 VOC Satin154.75Buy from eBay
Sherwin-Williams Finish 1 FC750-1 2.1 VOC SatinSherwin-Williams Finish 1 FC750-1 2.1 VOC Satin$78.31Buy from Amazon

Satin Vs Eggshell For Bathroom: Which One To Choose?

Whenever it comes to decorating your bathroom, people always tend to go beyond their limits. It is because this is the most frequently visited place in your house after the bedroom.

Also, a bathroom shows the hygiene of your entire home. So obviously you would want it to be as shiny as possible. In this case, you should always pick Satin over Eggshell.

Final Verdict

No matter how much of a good neighborhood you’re living in, if your house is not perfectly decorated for you, there will be no peace of mind.

That’s why you should plan carefully, taking every factor discussed in this article into account, and then decide whether you should go for the Sherwin Williams Eggshell or Satin.

Both of these paints can be used to coat the walls as well as the wooden furniture in your home. So before starting to pick colors, measure the architecture, lighting, and space of your house and then choose wisely.



Which looks better: eggshell or satin?

It all depends on how shiny you want your walls or furniture to be. If you are looking for something with a beautiful luster, then you obviously should go for Satin.

However, if your house is more like a period style home, you can choose Eggshell as it looks great or woodwork and walls.

Is Benjamin Moore eggshell the same as Sherwin Williams satin?

Some businesses switch around the sheen names among their product lines. For instance, Sherwin Williams satin = Benjamin Moore eggshell.

Does eggshell paint look lighter than satin?

Sherwin Williams Satin reflects more light than Eggshell, and it also has a velvety touch in the coating. On the other hand, the Eggshell reflects almost no light and has a matt finish, so it doesn’t shine like Satin.